What is Acquiescence?
Action or inaction which recognizes that a transaction exists and that it is voidable but which serves to bind a person legally even though not necessarily intended as such.
Examples and Case Studies
Real-Life Example
Imagine a scenario where Bob sells a piece of land to Alice. After the sale, it is discovered that the contract had some irregularities that could make the transaction voidable. However, Alice, by her actions, such as making improvements to the land and paying property taxes, implicitly accepts the transaction's validity. Her inaction in challenging the irregularities indicates acquiescence, legally binding her to the transaction despite its potential voidability.
Case Study: Smith v. Jones
In the case of Smith v. Jones, Smith leased a commercial property to Jones under a contract that contained several errors. Despite knowing about these errors, Jones continued to operate his business, pay rent, and make leasehold improvements without objection. Smith later tried to void the lease due to the contract errors, but the court ruled that Jones's continued use and investment in the property constituted acquiescence, thereby binding him to the lease terms.
Case Study: Brown v. Green
In Brown v. Green, Brown sold shares in a company to Green under a contract that Green could have voided due to misrepresentations. However, Green attended shareholder meetings, received dividends, and participated in company decisions for several years without raising any objections. When Green eventually attempted to void the contract, the court found that Green's actions demonstrated acquiescence, making the contract binding despite the initial misrepresentations.
Legal Requirements
| Requirement | Description |
|---|---|
| Knowledge | The party must be aware of the facts that make the transaction voidable. |
| Action or Inaction | The party's actions or failure to act must indicate acceptance of the transaction. |
| Implication of Acceptance | The party's conduct must imply acknowledgment and acceptance of the transaction's validity. |
| Legal Binding | The party's actions or inaction legally bind them to the transaction, despite its voidability. |
Common Issues and Disputes
Common issues in cases involving acquiescence often include:
- Determining whether the party had knowledge of the transaction's voidability.
- Assessing the actions or inaction that imply acceptance of the transaction.
- Evaluating the extent to which the party's conduct binds them legally to the transaction.
- Deciding if the initial transaction's irregularities are significant enough to consider voidability.
Key Points
- Acquiescence involves accepting a voidable transaction through action or inaction.
- Knowledge of the transaction's voidability is crucial for acquiescence to apply.
- Actions that indicate acceptance can legally bind a party to a transaction.
- Acquiescence can occur even without the party's explicit intention to be bound.
Further Reading
For more detailed information, see our related Contracts terms:
Pass the Bar, Guaranteed
BarPrepHero Premium offers the most complete collection of real bar exam questions licensed directly from NCBE (the organization that writes the exam).